I actually like it quite a bit, but I'm going to give the author what he was asking for and say that I hate it.
First of all, I love the piano piece. I think it is very moody by itself. I don't think you need the endless rain. At first, the rain and thunder sounds cool, but it gets old rather quickly. Maybe turn it down a little, to be more subtle. I think the original piece is a little empty, maybe, and this version is a little to crowded. Something in between will be perfect!
Thanks for the notes, I definitely agree with you. The main reason for the rain was that I too knew the main piece was too empty, the ambiance filled in some of the blanks for me, for now. I agree it's a bit crowded, and a bit repetitive at that. One day it'll be a complete piece, with more variation in melody, and less reliant on rain ambiance, so goes the plan. Thanks for the kind words and honest review, much appreciated.
I'm so happy right now!!!
This is some amazing work! I think even if I was suicidal, this song would make me want to buy a kid some cotton candy and a cloud-clubhouse. Awesome!
They should play this in the background on the Suicide Help-me Hotline.
newgrounds.com — Your #1 online entertainment & artist community! All your base are belong to us.